Please look at the article and answer the following questions:
- What is the purpose of a Sovereignty Bill? How does it achieve this purpose?
- Who are the Eurosceptics?
- What was the referendum mentioned in the article about?
- Why is the question of the European single currency especially important in Britain?
From Times Online
November 4, 2009
David Cameron promises Sovereignty Bill to stop Britain losing power to Brussels
Francis Elliott, Deputy Political Editor
David Cameron announced today that an incoming Tory administration would introduce a Sovereignty Bill to enshrine British powers, but defied Eurosceptics by appearing to rule out complete confrontation with Brussels. The Conservative leader confirmed that he was dropping his pledge to give voters a referendum on the Lisbon Treaty because such a vote would be meaningless.
Spelling out his new Europe policy, Mr Cameron also made clear that renegotiating the return of powers from Brussels was not a priority for a Tory government. In his only significant concession to Eurosceptic MPs, however, he announced that his administration would seek to pass a UK Sovereignty Bill "to make it clear that ultimate authority stays in this country, in our Parliament".
The Tory leader acknowledged that his campaign for a referendum on the Lisbon Treaty was over after its signature yesterday by the Czech President Vaclav Klaus. The signature meant that the treaty had now been ratified by all 27 European Union member states and would pass into law while EU members chose a new president and foreign policy supremo.
"We cannot hold a referendum and magically make those posts or the Lisbon Treaty itself disappear, any more than we could hold a referendum to stop the sun rising in the morning," he went on," Mr Cameron told a press conference. But he went on: "We will make sure that this never, ever happens again. Never again should it be possible for a British government to transfer power to the European Union without the say of the British people in a referendum."
The Conservative leader said that people would "resent" the fact that there would not be the referendum that was promised by Tony Blair and Gordon Brown. A Conservative government would amend the European Communities Act 1972 to prohibit the transfer of power to the EU without a referendum. That would cover any future attempt to take Britain into the European single currency, he said.
"We will give the British people a referendum lock to which only they should hold the key, a commitment very similar to that which exists in Ireland," Mr Cameron added. "This is a major constitutional development, but I believe it’s now the only way to reassure the British people that powers cannot be given away without their explicit approval in a referendum."
The Tory leader also promised to pass a Sovereignty Act to ensure the UK Parliament retains its primacy, much in the same way that Germany's Constitutional Court ensures that EU instruments do not undermine the constitution of that country. He said: "Because we have no written constitution, unlike many other EU countries, we have no explicit legal guarantee that the last word on our laws stays in Britain. There is therefore a danger that, over time, our courts might come to regard ultimate authority as resting with the EU.
"So as well as making sure that further power cannot be handed to the EU without a referendum, we will also introduce a new law, in the form of a United Kingdom Sovereignty Bill, to make it clear that ultimate authority stays in this country, in our Parliament." He added: "This is not about Westminster striking down individual items of EU legislation. It is about an assurance that the final word on our laws is here in Britain.
"It would simply put Britain on a par with Germany, where the German Constitutional Court has consistently upheld - including most recently on the Lisbon treaty - that ultimate authority lies with the bodies established by the German Constitution."
an economist's opinion (EURO-sceptic):
ReplyDeletehttp://www.timesonline.co.uk/tol/comment/leading_article/article5446480.ece
This is interesting in the light of what our coursebook says on referenda!
ReplyDelete"If the government wants to make an important change in the way that the country is run - to change, for example, the electoral system or the powers of the Prime Minister - it does not have to ask the people. It does not even have to have a special vote in Parliament in which an especially high proportion of MPs must agree."
So I guess it is not that the British people are so used to making themselves heard...
or it is simply unusual that the powers of the whole system (e.g. legislative) are limited by another organisation... guess the British are not used to a higher authority then their government.
ReplyDeleteBoth comments are wise and touch upon important issues - indeed, Britain is the textbook model (par excellence, if you like) of a representational democracy, where it is the representatives of the people in the parliament who make all the decisions for them, exactly so that the people would not have to bother with state business that they do not really care about. In fact the only referendum was held to approve - to approve! - the membership in the EU, 2 years after Britain's accession, and the reason for it was that this was the time that the first positive effects of the membership began to show. So the politicians wouldn't want to risk anything.
ReplyDeleteNow that David Cameron brings up the idea of constitutionalising the method of referendums is clearly part of the campaign hype and plays on the traditional British rebuff of anything that looks to limit the power of the parliament. Actually, the only civil war broke out in Britain when the King tried to do just that, and he was executed after it. The parliament's sovereignty in Britain is not a joke, it's deadly serious.
Still, more and more people have mistrust towards its working and become indifferent to politics, but that is again a different matter.