Culture and Politics in the Light of Recent Events

Monday, March 22, 2010

"Brown shred into pieces"

This is a fine example of the polite heatedness of the debates taking place in the House of Commons. The two protagonists are the Prime Minister Gordon Brown and opposition leader David Cameron.



Why is David Cameron attacking the Prime Minister on a not-called general election? What is the story behind this?

4 comments:

  1. At 4:22 D. Cameron's manifestation is in contradiction to the following sentence from our nice book: "The fellow MP concerned may be sitting directly opposite, but the MP never says 'you'.

    But this is a really entertaining video :)

    I had a question, why people stand up during the debate.. and I think if The Mr. Honorable SPEAKER (who btw speaks almost the less in the whole parliament) would let them speak there wouldn't be such noise in the chamber.

    I wonder whether this is how an "adjournment debate" always looks like.. or was it the "main business" (or the prayer) session?

    ReplyDelete
  2. The timing of the general elections is in the hands of the Prime Minister, thus, throughout history, the PMs called for elections when they felt they were popular to ensure another term in power for themselves. However, "BBC political editor Nick Robinson suggested the main reason for not calling a snap election would be an unfavourable poll of marginal seats showing a swing to Tories." Brown was insecure about the results, but Cameron was a little over-confident according to me. Take a look at this article about the backgrounds of the debate, with very differing opinions about the likely outcome: http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/7031749.stm

    ReplyDelete
  3. In my opinion, Brown still has not called an election because his popularity is quite low in Britain at the moment, and he is waiting for a time when it would get higher. But, I also think that, Cameron is rather over-confident too. So, I mostly agree with Edina. :)
    By the way, is that really the way a debate goes in the British Parliament? I mean, why don't the MPs listen to each other in a bigger silence? There is too much noise during the speeches I think...

    ReplyDelete
  4. Laci: well, yes, and I think it was actually very rude of Mr Cameron in the end to address the PM like he did. And I believe the session was the question time of the Prime Minister. By the way, how do we call "question time" here in Hungary?

    Edina: the article indeed offers the explanations to what has happened after Gordon Brown took on the premiership. In fact, it is general custom in Britain, that if a new prime minister and therefore a new government is formed following an internal party decision, they are reinforced in their positions by calling an immediate election. This is what e.g. Anthony Eden did after Churchill chose him as his follower in 1955. Gordon Brown was at the peak of his popularity right after he began his work as PM, and many say to this day that that would have been the right time to win a 5-year term in office.

    Zsofi: if the debate that is going on is important and the chamber is full, yes, the debate looks just like that. It is indeed very entertaining, it seems that the MPs are really passionate about their jobs. And maybe they are. Still, they are very polite most of the time, nevertheless. I'll never forget once hearing a Cabinet member beginning his speech in the Commons with the words "I would like to say thank you to the Opposition for their work in this matter." I wonder when we are going to hear something like that in Hungary.

    ReplyDelete