I have chosen two articles for you to look into for next week, one is on multiculturalism in Britain and how the notion of being "British" has (or has not) changed in the last few years, with more and more migrants settling in the country and now second and third generation British people being born of Caribbean, Middle Eastern and African origin. The city most acutely concerned with migration is of course London, that in the past decades has truly become a "showcase" of cultures, with people from all around the world living together.
The second article is about the end of a massive wave of migration from Central Europe to Britain, which started with the "Big Bang enlargement" of the European Union in 2004. As this latter topic bears great relevance to us in Hungary - probably you also have relatives or friends who went abroad to work for some time, or maybe you yourself have done it - I think it is worth discussing the reasons and the consequences of these movements.
Please read them through, they are not easy at the first glance, studded with culture-related and political vocabulary, but that is exactly what we are going to go through in class. Concentrate especially on the following points:
No. 1
- Why has multiculturalism become a derogatory term in the last few years?
- In what ways does the co-habitation of different ethnic groups lead to confrontations?
- Do you agree that multiculturalism can contribute to a “deliberate weakening of [the] collective identity” of a society?
- What do different political parties and political bodies say on the matter?
- What do you think of the three reasons the article summons in protection of multiculturalism in Britain?
- And about the chances of “promoting a new, inclusive Britishness”?
BagehotIn praise of multiculturalismAlmost everyone now agrees that it has failed. Has it really?
Jun 14th 2007 | From The Economist print editionSteve O'Brian
SWEAR WORDS, like everything else, are subject to fashion. Since the London bombings of 2005, a new obscenity has entered the lexicon, alongside the anatomical and the blasphemous: multiculturalism. Once it connoted curry and the Notting Hill carnival; these days, when applied to British politicians or their policies, “multiculturalist” is almost as derogatory a term as “socialist” or “neocon”. Even more than they agree about most other things, the main political parties are united in their conviction that multiculturalism is a perniciously naive idea whose time has gone, or ought never to have come at all.
Last week, for example, David Cameron, the Tory leader, warned an unenraptured audience of Islamic leaders about the dangers of “cultural separatism” in Muslim communities. “The creed of multiculturalism,” he alleged—meaning, roughly, a combination of indulgence and subsidy for minorities and their institutions—had contributed to a “deliberate weakening of our collective identity”. Two Labour ministers, meanwhile, suggested the creation of an annual holiday to help cultivate a renewed sense of Britishness. A commission set up by the government last year, to advise on segregation and extremism, recommended this week that less money be spent on providing civic information in Urdu, Arabic and so on, and more on unmulticultural English lessons. The need to rethink Britishness for a post-multicultural age is a regular theme for Gordon Brown, the (Scottish) prime-minister-not-much-longer-in-waiting.
The shock of hearing a suicide-bomber's video testament delivered in a Yorkshire accent—hitherto more associated with cricket commentary than terrorism—spelled the end for multiculturalism. But even before the bombings the word was becoming a slur. Rioting by Asian youths across northern England in the summer of 2001 forced curry-house multiculturalists to confront the reality that government nonchalance had helped to engender. As well as the burned cars, they saw fossilised social mores and the angry alienation of second- and third-generation Pakistani and Bangladeshi immigrants, some of whom profess more allegiance to the global umma than to Britain.
All that is real, tragic and terrifying, and becomes more so with every blood-curdling terrorist plot that British police uncover. All the same, poor, deplored multiculturalism has been much less bad than its many detractors now claim.
There are three reasons why the legions of anti-multiculturalists are wrong. First, left to their own devices many immigrants to Britain have prospered. Indians and some other minorities do better than whites in schools. There are many types of British Muslims, and some of them are moving up and out. The 2005 bombers, it now seems, were shaped and motivated as much by strife within Muslim communities—fanatical Islamism serving as a perverse form of intergenerational rebellion—as by schisms between Muslims and wider British society. Nor have immigration and multiculturalism led to so very much restlessness among the natives. The nasty, if clownish, British National Party has occasionally picked up the odd council seat, but it is a piffling force compared with far-right outfits elsewhere in Europe.
Second, multiculturalism's detractors tend to concentrate on the easy targets. It is plainly true, for example, that Britain should anathemise egregious practices such as forced marriage or “honour killing”. That government commission and others are right to emphasise English lessons, especially for women, since an inability to speak it harms their children's prospects as well as their own. The commission is right again to imply that too much funding has historically and divisively been offered to community groups that cater to only one ethnicity or religion. (The commission also advocated better cultural preparation for new arrivals, for example to help them understand the British philosophy of queuing and thus avoid ruckuses at bus-stops and post offices.) But less tends to be said about what, in the end, are the most important determinants of segregation, namely housing and education. “Multicultural” policies—letting people, by and large, live and educate their children where they like—may have inadvertently created neighbourhoods and schools in which almost every face is the same colour. But as well as being illiberal, most of the alternatives would probably create more trouble and anger than they prevent.
Americans in glass houses
Finally—and for all the disparaging talk about Londonistan, capital of Eurabia—other countries, including those where the disparagement of multiculturalism is sharpest, have less to teach Britain about integration than is often assumed. That is partly because they have failures too, and partly because their circumstances are too different to be meaningfully compared. Mr Cameron talked admiringly about the American solidarity embodied in the pledge of allegiance and Mount Rushmore. Yet in Chicago and elsewhere, black Americans are more ghettoised than any minority is anywhere in Britain (they also intermarry less than blacks in Britain). Slavery, of course, makes black Americans a special case—but so are any number of British Muslims. Many are refugees; others are from families who migrated to the old imperial motherland from backward parts of Pakistan and Bangladesh, to work in British factories that subsequently closed. Many of their American counterparts may indeed stick the Stars and Stripes on their front lawn as devoutly as do other hyphenated Americans; but, apart from their faith, they may not have much in common with the Muslims of Burnley or Oldham.
The vogue for promoting a new, inclusive Britishness is well-intentioned, but probably doomed. National identities cannot be confected—and besides, the British already have one. Privacy and freedom are two of its nicer components, and multiculturalism, for all its failings, has been a fine expression of it.
No. 2
- What has triggered the Polish immigration to Britain? What made it possible?
- What jobs and positions have immigrants been taking at the first place?
- How do you think the massive immigration affected the British society and what was the general opinion on it?
From The Times
Tide turns as Poles end great migration
Alexi Mostrous and Christine Seib
February 16, 2008
Polish builder Aric Jenac, 33, building at a home in London (Susannah Ireland / The Times)
A wave of immigration that helped to fuel Britain’s early 21st century boom is over, as the Polish plumber and thousands like him go home. The Times has established that, for the first time since they began arriving en masse four years ago, more UK-based Poles are returning to their homeland than are entering Britain. Statistics show that only 38,680 Poles signed up to the Government’s register of migrant workers in the third quarter of 2007, a slump of 18 per cent from the previous year. Polish officials say that Poles leaving the country outnumber thoses coming in.
Hard statistics on the number of Poles leaving Britain do not exist. There are no embarkation controls on EU members so they are are not counted out. But Polish officials, British employment agencies and the Polish media all believe that the tide of immigration has turned. Since Poland joined the EU in 2004, 274,065 Poles have signed up for work permits. They make up 66 per cent of all applications from Eastern European countries. But a combination of tightening economic conditions in this country, a comparatively weak pound and an unprecendented surge in the Polish economy has made it unattractive for Poles to remain. “At the end of last year we saw the tipping point,” Krzysztof Trepczynski, Minister for Economic Development at the Polish Embassy in London, said. “It’s a real change. There are now definitely more Poles going back to Poland.
Jan Mokrzycki, president of the Federation of Poles in Great Britain, said: “The first thing that’s been hit is the builders. There’s no doubt about it. Many aren’t prepared to wait for the construction boom that’s going to happen for the Olympics in 2012. “Also, the Polish economy is experiencing an upturn. The zloty is at a high and although we’re experiencing inflation here and in Poland, it’s not as noticable in Poland because the currency is strong.” Half of the estimated one million British-based Poles are expected to return home, said the Centre for International Relations, a Warsaw-based think-tank.
Chris Zietkowski, 34, a Polish painter and decorator, told The Times that he wanted to return home this year. “Two years ago I could make five times the amount of money here than I could in Poland,” he said. “Now the wages are about the same and the living costs in the UK are much higher. There is a lot of work in Poland, probably more than in the UK. It’s a good time to go back.” Mr Zietkowski added that many of his friends were also thinking about returning. “The feeling is: why be away from your family and your home-land for no reason?”
The tide of immigration prompted supermarkets to introduce ranges of Polish products as they sought to tap into the substantial spending power of the new arrivals. Polish newspapers and radio stations sprang up. Libraries started stocking Polish books. The young immigrants, most of whom were aged between 18 and 25, quickly infiltrated the building and plumbing industries, drawing praise for their work ethic and low prices. Last year’s downturn in the British building industry has prompted many to return home.
Kasia Popyla, 23, is a student physio-therapist who has just returned to Poland. “I used to make £800 per month,” she said. “Since the summer I’ve watched the zloty value of my savings, which are in pounds, fall lower and lower. “At the end of the day we are Polish, we left in our early 20s and are coming back to get married and watch our kids grow up in Poland.”
Cost of living743,000 Eastern Europeans applied to register for British jobs between 2004 and 2007468,000 Poles successfully applied, 66 per cent of the applications1 million Poles estimated to have migrated to Britain£1 equals 7.23 Polish zloty (2004)£1 equals 4.83 Polish zloty (2008)8% of Poles left the country in the past three years, fleeing 16 per cent unemployment£800 Polish monthly average wage (2003)£1,967 English monthly average wage (2003)Source: Home Office and Poland’s statistic office


Reading through these articles, I was wondering what my reactions would be towards a mass of foreigners working in Hungary, first not being able to say a single hungarian word, then after some years of experience and assimilation leaving and taking the money out of the country (afterall, they spend their collected money in their own country). Actually in this example I put together everything that would upset me, and the situation in this case is even worse, because unemployment is so high in Hungary and payments, salaries are not that attractive here, so I don't see the point why a mass of immigrants would come here to work, but!
ReplyDeleteConsidering Britain, I've heard a lot of stories about people who went there in search of jobs, but they weren't able to say a single word in English! This is just something that I've never understood. If I were British, I don't think that I would tolerate a shop assistant in my own country to whom I have to explain what I want with arms and legs. Of course I cannot see this from a British point of wiew, maybe they're got used to this, but still, I don't think that I could tolerate this.
Furthermore, I also think that what the Polish do is not really fair. They benefited from the country as much as they could, and now they go home. What did provide in return? Nice houses, repaired taps, proficiency in what they do. OK, but after this? After they went home?
Of course the situation is not as bad as I introduced, there is some exaggeration, and still, I could write an essay or research about this topic, but I think there is some truth in this comment..
What do you think? Feel free to argue! :)
Csilla
*What did they provide in return?
ReplyDeleteIt is definitely weird to have a mass of people suddenly living in your country who don't know anything about you, your language, your customs and the way things work there. And this is exactly what has been going on in Britain ever since the colonial period, but especially in the last 50 years, so they sort of got used to it. Tolerating the situation is termed "multiculturalism", problems only come when things turn ugly (bombings) and people would like to go back to the old times. Only they can't.
ReplyDeleteAbout the Polish immigrants, we must not forget that Britain needed this workforce, there were branches of British economy that were virtually empty, no people wishing to do certain kinds of work - most prominently in the building sector and household services (plumbing, of course becoming the emblematic job for Eastern-Central Europeans). It is by no accident that Britain was among the first (three) countries that opened their markets to foreign workers. So it is not that Poles forced themselves on poor Britons, they actually made a very useful contribution. Nothing proves this more than the desperation that they are leaving two years before the London Olympics when massive amounts of building is planned and construction workers will be needed like never before.
Similarly, immigrants mean money for the economy, and quite a few quids: an extra million people paying taxes directly through their salaries and indirectly through buying goods (even illegal workers need to live on stuff) can mean a huge boost. Plus, these people are not students, not pensioners but active working population that don't cost a lot to the social system either.
And, as it seems, they are leaving when the circumstances are not right - this was the idea of the whole Economic Community and the freedom of movement within it: to use the comparative advantages offered by different regions to the best possible outcome.
I wouldn't go to any place to work where I don't speak some of the local language, but there are actually a lot of people who did it and managed quite well, so probably this is not such a great problem either. I would say, let the markets decide whom they need, and those not up to the challenge will have to come home anyway. But that's, of course, the capitalist speaking.
First, thank you for your substantial response, things became much clearer and collected to me. Or I could say: (At least partly) I understood Britain's culture and politics in the light of recent events. :)For some reason this has always been a blurred topic for me.
ReplyDeleteYes, I also considered that these workers also pay taxes directly and indirectly, which means an income to the state. And I guessed that it was not by accident that these immigrants appeared there, but I wasn't sure about the reason. And now, I have further questions.
After all, wouldn't it be better and more convenient to the Britons and the state if these certain kinds of works that now they're not wishing to do were still done by them? I'm sure that somehow the state could come up with alluring rebates for those who would be willing to do these works.
Like here in Hungary: Less people applied to be engineers, therefore the education system reacted in a way that the point limit (I'm not sure whether it is the proper term for 'ponthatár') became lower. And as there is a mass of applications for the faculty of arts which is now less needed, it became more difficult to get into these departments.
Why don't Britons do the same? Giving rebates for those working in the building sector, household services, etc. Or is it more convenient for them to get these works done by immigrants? Because their rebate, preference is that Britain allows them to work there, which doesn't cost the state extra money or much effort apart from tolerating them in their own country?
I'm wondering if there are proper answers to these questions which I'm just not aware of.
Csilla
Yes, of course it'd be possible to train more people in sectors where there is a demand for workers, but it takes time - those people have to learn those extra skills first, and, well, why providing extra funds or rebates for such purposes, if the workforce is there, ready, and even cheaper than it would be from any British source. Let's not forget that most of the Central Europeans went to Britain to work for the minimum wage, which is a marvellous pay for them but usually not acceptable to the British. But of course, now it is beginning to change.
ReplyDeleteHaving said that, the government is aware of the need to adjust training to market demands, and it is feebly mentioned in the current programme of the Secretary of State for Education and Skills, but I feel that a more pressing issue is to increase the number of young people staying in whatever kind of education after 16, as "the UK ranks 24th out of 29 developed nations" in this respect.
It is an interesting question what the parties are now proposing in their election programmes to solve the problem of unemployment and underrepresented economic sectors. Please look into it if you have the time.
The good link to the programme:
ReplyDeletehttp://www.official-documents.gov.uk/document/cm67/6768/6768.pdf